Some people emerge a few hours later, their egos bruised and their intelligence a bit insulted, because they still think that the flat earth is nonsense but are frustrated that they can’t seem to answer many of the arguments they’ve just encountered. That search for help usually is on the Internet, whereupon they quickly find a slew of websites and videos promoting the flat earth, but precious little, if any, refuting it. ![]() However, rarely having the knowledge readily at hand to refute the case for a flat earth, most people who take this approach soon look for help. The most common response is to dismiss the person asking the questions as a crank or fool, because “everyone knows that the earth is round.” The other response is to pay more attention to the “flat-earthers,” looking for errors in their facts or logic. Once the space photos of a spherical earth are shot down, the vast majority of people usually have one of two responses. Belief in a spherical earth goes back much earlier than this, so obviously there must be better responses. Furthermore, those sorts of photos have been available only for a little more than a half-century. Indeed, because we all know that it is very easy to fake such photos, perhaps those photos don’t prove much after all. However, the clever speaker will respond that such photos easily can be faked. When cornered in this manner, people generally respond with the observation that we have photos from space that clearly show a spherical earth. When someone comes along, such as this young man, who has given this some thought and begins to raise what appear to be simple objections to the earth’s spherical shape, it doesn’t take much to fluster most people. Most people have not given this question any thought, because they have been taught their entire lives that the earth is spherical, so why worry about it? Consequently, with no idea of the reasons we know that the earth is spherical, most people long ago entered a complacent state of more or less taking someone else’s word for the matter. ![]() Consequently, with no idea of the reasons we know that the earth is spherical, most people long ago entered a complacent state of more or less taking someone else’s word for the matter. So much for our modern smug superiority over the supposedly ignorant people of the past. Rarely could any of my students give a good reason why the earth is spherical. The question of the earth’s true shape had been settled two millennia before Columbus. Most of my students were surprised to learn that the facts of history are very different. Supposedly, with our sophistication and intelligence today, we know better than the ignorant people of the past. By raising the question, I challenged our cultural mythology that, until the time of Christopher Columbus five centuries ago, nearly everyone thought the earth was flat. In my years at the university, I always asked the same sort of question in my introductory astronomy classes to motivate my students into thinking more deeply. Rather, he finds the topic interesting and the discussion of it stimulating. Mind you, this young man does not actually believe that the earth is flat. Recently I had a conversation with some people about a Christian young man they know who frequently argues that the earth is flat. You see, the earth could be both round and flat, if it were disk shaped. Or, more specifically, an earth that is spherical. ![]() Many people will probably wonder why it is necessary to write an article defending a round earth.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |